View Document Text
Part 2A of Form ADV: Firm Brochure
Islay Capital Management, LLC
dba McDonald Capital Management
8001 Quaker Avenue
Suite J
Lubbock, TX 79424
Telephone: (806) 744-8617
Facsimile: (806) 762-8555
www.mcdcap.com
E-mail: emcdonald@mcdcap.com
February 20, 2026
This brochure provides information about the qualifications and business practices of McDonald Capital
Management (hereinafter “MCM” or “firm” or “we”). If you have any questions about the contents of this brochure,
please contact us at (806) 744-8617 or at emcdonald@mcdcap.com. The information in this brochure has not been
approved or verified by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission or by any state securities authority.
Additional information about MCM is available on the SEC’s website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. You can search
this site by a unique identifying number, known as a CRD number. The CRD number for MCM is 114531.
Item 2.
Summary of Material Changes
There have been no material changes since our last amendment on February 25, 2025.
2 | P ag e
Item 3.
Table of Contents
Item 2. Summary of Material Changes ....................................................................................................................... 2
Item 3. Table of Contents ........................................................................................................................................... 3
Item 4. Advisory Business .......................................................................................................................................... 4
Item 5. Fees and Compensation .................................................................................................................................. 5
Item 6. Performance-Based Fees and Side-By-Side Management ............................................................................. 7
Item 7. Types of Clients ............................................................................................................................................. 7
Item 8. Methods of Analysis, Investment Strategies and Risk of Loss ...................................................................... 7
Item 10. Other Financial Industry Activities and Affiliations ............................................................................ 11
Item 11. Code of Ethics, Participation in Client Transactions and Personal Trading ......................................... 11
Item 12. Brokerage Practices .............................................................................................................................. 12
Item 13. Review of Accounts .............................................................................................................................. 15
Item 14. Client Referrals and Other Compensation ............................................................................................ 15
Item 15. Custody ................................................................................................................................................. 15
Item 16. Investment Discretion ........................................................................................................................... 16
Item 17. Voting Client Securities ........................................................................................................................ 16
Item 18. Financial Information ........................................................................................................................... 17
Item 2. Educational Background and Business Experience ...................................................................................... 19
Item 3. Disciplinary Information .............................................................................................................................. 19
Item 4. Other Business Activities ............................................................................................................................. 19
Item 5. Additional Compensation ............................................................................................................................. 19
Item 6. Supervision................................................................................................................................................... 19
Item 2. Educational Background and Business Experience ...................................................................................... 22
Item 3. Disciplinary Information .............................................................................................................................. 22
Item 4. Other Business Activities ............................................................................................................................. 22
Item 5. Additional Compensation ............................................................................................................................. 22
Item 6. Supervision................................................................................................................................................... 22
3 | P ag e
Item 4.
Advisory Business
MCM is a SEC-registered investment adviser (SEC File Number 801-61327) with its principal place of
business located in Lubbock, Texas. Our firm has been in business since 1990, with Eric Craig McDonald
as majority owner and Chief Compliance Officer. Tyler Bee Sturdivant is a minority owner.
Discretionary assets under our firm’s management were $ 357,658,014 as of December 31, 2025.
Portfolio Management Services and Financial Planning
MCM provides individually tailored investment portfolios and financial planning services, and manages
private funds. Our firm provides continuous advice to a client regarding the investment of client funds
based on the individual needs of the client. Through personal discussions in which goals and objectives
based on a client's particular circumstances are established, we develop a client's personal investment
policy or investment plan and create and manage a portfolio based on that policy or plan. During our
data-gathering process, we determine the client’s individual objectives, time horizons, risk tolerance,
and liquidity needs. We may also review and discuss a client’s prior investment history, as well as family
composition and background.
We provide advisory services for accounts on a discretionary basis. For these discretionary accounts, we
will implement transactions without seeking prior client consent. On occasion, we will provide review
and trading services for non-discretionary accounts for existing clients if requested.
Account supervision is guided by the stated objectives of the client (i.e., maximum capital appreciation,
growth, income, or growth and income), as well as tax considerations. Clients may impose reasonable
restrictions on investing in certain securities, types of securities, or industry sectors.
Our investment recommendations are not limited to any specific product or service offered by a broker
dealer or insurance company and will primarily include advice regarding the following instruments:
• “No-load” or “load-waived” mutual funds, exchange traded funds and notes
• Equity securities
• Fixed income securities
• Preferred securities
• Closed-end mutual funds
Occasionally, we may also recommend the following instruments:
• Warrants
• Commercial paper
• Certificates of Deposit
• Municipal securities
• US government securities
• Option contracts on securities
4 | P ag e
Environmental, Social and Governance Investment Services (“ESG” investing)
McDonald provides ESG investing to institutional clients upon their request. MCM runs exception
report screening for certain revenue streams to exclude for investment. These guidelines are client
directed.
Consulting Services
Clients can also receive investment advice on a more limited basis. This may include advice on only an
isolated area(s) of concern such as retirement planning, reviewing a client's existing portfolio, or any
other specific topic. Additionally, we provide advice on non-securities matters. Generally, this is in
connection with the rendering of estate planning, insurance, and/or annuity advice. We also provide
administrative services if requested by a client.
Financial Planning Services
We provide financial planning services based on a client’s goals and objectives. We work with clients to
develop and implement a strategy for managing their finances including financial goals, investment
analysis, retirement planning, cash flow and debt management, college savings and estate planning.
Services in General
We tailor all of our portfolio management and consulting recommendations to the individual needs of
each client. All such recommendations are based on information gathered through client questionnaires,
electronic communications, telephone and in-person discussions.
Item 5.
Fees and Compensation
Portfolio Management Services
We charge an annual fee based on a percentage of assets under our management, in accordance with the
following tiered billing schedule:
Assets Under Management ($)
Annual Fee (%)
Up to $1,000,000
$1,000,001 to $5,000,000
$5,000,001 & up
1.00%
0.75%
0.50%
Pooled Investment Vehicle
MCM CCP/Baypine, LP does not charge a management fee. An annual 10% performance fee is charged
after initial capital has been returned.
Islay Multifactor Fund I, LP charges a 20% performance fee after a 5% hurdle. All fees are calculated by
the fund administrator.
5 | P ag e
When determining the breakpoints for fee billing, we will combine the value of household accounts.
Institutional and charitable accounts range from 0.50% to 0.60% based on assets and complexity of
investment policy statement. Some legacy clients have negotiated fees that differ from the above fee
schedule.
We will generally directly debit client custodial accounts for portfolio management fees.
Portfolio management fees are billed quarterly in arrears at the end of each calendar quarter, based upon
the portfolio value on the last day of that calendar quarter, pro-rated for additions and withdrawals.
Consulting Services
Clients receiving consulting services are billed at an hourly rate of $250. Consulting services fees are
due and payable once we deliver the contracted-for work product to the client.
Financial Planning Fees
We offer financial planning services starting at $1,000 per year, billed bi-annually in arrears. Fees vary
based on time and complexity.
Financial planning annual fees may be waived for clients with over $150,000 in assets under
management. Fees are billed at the client’s direction either Annually, Quarterly or Monthly.
Fees in General
Fees and account minimums for all services are negotiable based upon certain criteria and are at
McDonald’s discretion (i.e. anticipated future earning capacity, anticipated future additional assets,
dollar amount of assets to be managed, related accounts, account composition, negotiations with client,
competitive considerations, etc.). Discounts, not generally available to our advisory clients, may be
offered to family members and friends.
We may group certain related client accounts for the purposes of determining the account size and/or
annualized fee.
Certain legacy client agreements may be governed by fee schedules different from those listed above.
Any legacy holdings that are deemed to be unsupervised by our firm may be included in the client
reporting package and client will not pay a management fee on those assets.
Account Termination
Clients will have a period of five (5) business days from the date of signing the agreement to
unconditionally rescind the agreement and receive a full refund of all fees. Thereafter, the client may
terminate the agreement by providing us with a 30-day written notice at our principal place of business.
Upon termination of any account, any prepaid, unearned fees will be promptly refunded, and any earned,
unpaid fees will be due and payable.
6 | P ag e
Mutual Fund and ETF Fees and Expenses: All fees paid to our firm for investment advisory services
are separate and distinct from the fees and expenses charged by mutual funds and ETFs to their
shareholders. These fees and expenses are described in each fund's prospectus. These fees will
generally include a management fee, other fund expenses, and a possible distribution fee. A client
could invest in a mutual fund or and ETF directly, without the services of our firm. In that case, the
client would not receive the services provided by us which are designed, among other things, to assist
the client in determining which mutual fund or funds or ETFs are most appropriate to each client's
financial condition and objectives. Accordingly, the client should review both the fees charged by the
funds and ETFs and the fees charged by us to fully understand the total amount of fees to be paid by
the client and to thereby evaluate the advisory services being provided.
Brokerage and Custodial Fees
In addition to advisory fees paid to our firm, clients will also be responsible for all transaction,
brokerage, trade-away and custodial fees incurred as part of their account management. Please see Item
12 of this Brochure for important disclosures regarding our brokerage practices.
Item 6.
Performance-Based Fees and Side-By-Side Management
We charge a performance-based fee to accredited investors invested in the pooled investment vehicles
we manage.
Item 7.
Types of Clients
Our firm generally provides advisory services to individuals, high net worth individuals, pension and
profit sharing plans, trusts, estates, charitable organizations, corporations, other business entities and
pooled investment vehicles.
We generally impose a minimum relationship size under the respective client service segments.
• Separately Managed Accounts. The minimum relationship size is $250,000 and/or a minimum
annual fee of $2,500 as of March 1, 2009. However, no client's fee will exceed 3% of assets under
management per annum.
• Retirement Plan Services. There is no current minimum relationship size for this client group.
Under no circumstance will a client's fee exceed 2% per annum or exceed a fee amount governed
by retirement plan provision.
• Consulting Clients There is currently no minimum relationship size or minimum annual fee for
these clients.
Item 8.
Methods of Analysis, Investment Strategies and Risk of Loss
Our firm employs the following types of analysis to formulate client recommendations.
Fundamental Analysis: Fundamental analysis of a business involves analyzing its income statement,
financial statements and health, its management and competitive advantages, and its competitors and
markets. Fundamental analysis school of thought maintains that markets may mis-price a security in the
7 | P ag e
short run but that the "correct" price will eventually be reached. Profits can be made by trading the mis-
priced security and then waiting for the market to recognize its "mistake" and re-price the security.
Traditional measures of value such as dividend yield, market price to sales, book, cash flow and earnings
are examined in our investment process. However, fundamental analysis does not attempt to anticipate
market movements. This presents a potential risk, as the price of a security can move up or down along
with the overall market regardless of the economic and financial factors considered in evaluating the
stock. Therefore, unforeseen market conditions and/or company developments may result in significant
price fluctuations that can lead to investor losses.
Mutual fund and/or ETF analysis: We evaluate the experience and track record of the manager of the
mutual fund or ETF in an attempt to determine if that manager has demonstrated an ability to invest over
a period of time and in different economic conditions. We also look at the underlying assets in a mutual
fund or ETF in an attempt to determine if there is significant overlap in the underlying investments held
in other funds in the client’s portfolio. We also monitor the funds or ETFs in an attempt to determine if
they are continuing to follow their stated investment strategy.
A risk of mutual fund and/or ETF analysis is that, as in all securities investments, past performance does
not guarantee future results. A manager who has been successful may not be able to replicate that success
in the future. In addition, as we do not control the underlying investments in a fund or ETF, managers of
different funds held by the client may purchase the same security, increasing the risk to the client if that
security were to fall in value. There is also a risk that a manager may deviate from the stated investment
mandate or strategy of the fund or ETF, which could make the fund or ETF less suitable of the client’s
portfolio.
Technical analysis. We analyze past market movements and apply that analysis to the present in an
attempt to recognize recurring patterns of investor behavior and to potentially predict future price
movement.
Charting: In this type of technical analysis, we review charts of market and security activity in an attempt
to identify when the market is moving up or down and to predict when how long the trend may last and
when that trend might reverse. Technical analysis does not consider the underlying financial condition
of a company. This presents a risk in that a poorly managed or financially unsound company may
underperform regardless of market movement.
Risks for all forms of analysis: Our securities analysis method relies on the assumption that the
companies whose securities we purchase and sell, the rating agencies that review these securities, and
other publicly available sources of information about these securities, are providing accurate and
unbiased data. While we are alert to indications that data may be incorrect, there is always a risk that our
analysis may be compromised by inaccurate or misleading information.
MCM uses publicly available information from a variety of sources including but not limited to:
company reports and SEC filings, financial press, trade journals and other third-party research in the
investment process.
Our firm employs the following investment strategies to implement investment advice given to clients:
Global Tactical Asset Allocation ETF Model: MCM uses a global asset allocation model which seeks to
8 | P ag e
reallocate equity, fixed-income and cash assets quarterly with the goal of increasing risk-adjusted returns
by taking advantage of intermediate-term trends within the asset classes. The model rotates allocations
between asset classes including, Broad US Equity, US Dividend Equity, US Technology, US Small Cap
Equity, International EAFE, Emerging Market Equity, Long-Term US Treasuries, Short-Term US
Treasuries, Investment Grade Corporate Bonds, High Yield Bonds, Emerging Market Debt, International
Sovereign Bonds and Cash.
A risk to the Global Tactical Asset Allocation model is the possibility of being over/under invested in
market segments that are underperforming/outperforming a static (or fixed) portfolio mix of similar asset
classes.
EVA Spread Equity Screen: MCM uses this quantitative equity model as an equity allocation. The model
screens from the Russell 3000 Index and provides a list of firms that pass our screening criteria of value,
earnings momentum, and quality (based on Economic Value Added and low debt). The model is run every
3 months and portfolios are adjusted accordingly.
A risk to the EVA Spread Model is concentration risk. Due to the criteria of the filter, few stocks may be
included in the sleeve and any one sector or may be over-represented in the equity sleeve. Also, at different
levels of overall market valuation, company size may be represented differently in this screened portfolio.
We do not expect this equity sleeve to represent the broad indices and performance can be significantly
different than major indexes.
ROIC Equity Screen: MCM uses this quantitative equity model as an equity allocation. This model
screens through and rank orders securities within the Russel 3000 Index based on multiple balance sheet
metrics, the most important being a high Return on Capital Employed. Due to the nature of the balance
sheet screening, Financials and Utilities are excluded. The top 50 stocks screened through the model are
added to the equity sleeve on a quarterly basis and are equally weighted.
Risks to this model include: possible sector concentration risk where any one sector may be over-
represented in the model during any quarter; and due to the equal weighting of securities, this model may
not provide returns similar to traditional capitalization weighted market indexes.
Long-term purchases: We mostly purchase securities with the idea of holding them in the clients account
for a year or longer. We may do this because we believe the securities to be currently undervalued or
because we want exposure to a particular asset class over time, regardless of the short-term projection
for this class.
A risk in a long-term purchase strategy is that, by holding the security for this length of time, we may
not take advantages of short-term gains that could be profitable to a client. Moreover, if our predictions
are incorrect, a security may decline sharply in value before we make the decision to sell.
Short-term purchases: At times, we may also purchase securities with the idea of selling them within a
relatively short time (typically a year or less). We do this in an attempt to take advantage of conditions
that we believe will soon result in a price swing in the securities we purchase. A risk in a short-term
purchase is the potential for sudden losses if the anticipated price swing does not materialize. Moreover,
should the anticipated price swing not materialize, we are left with the option of having a long-term
investment in a security that was designed to be a short-term purchase, or potentially taking a loss. In
addition, this strategy involves more frequent trading than does a longer-term strategy, and will result in
increased brokerage and other transaction-related costs, as well as less favorable tax treatment of short-
term capital gains.
9 | P ag e
A risk in a short-term purchase strategy is that, should the anticipated price swing not materialize, we
are left with the option of having a long-term investment in a security that was designed to be a short-
term purchase, or potentially taking a loss. In addition, this strategy involves more frequent trading than
does a longer-term strategy, and will result in increased brokerage and other transaction-related costs, as
well as less favorable tax treatment of short-term capital gains.
Trading: We purchase securities with the idea of selling them very quickly (typically within 30 days or
less). We do this in an attempt to take advantage of our predictions of brief price swings.
Short sales: We borrow shares of a stock for your portfolio from someone who owns the stock on a
promise to replace the shares on a future date at a certain price. We then sell the shares we have borrowed.
On the agreed-upon future date, we buy the same stock and return the shares to the original owner. We
engage in short selling based on our determination that the stock will go down in price after we have
borrowed the shares. If the stock has gone down since we purchased the shares from the original owner,
we keep the difference.
One risk in selling short is that losses are theoretically unlimited; we are obligated to repurchase the
stock no matter how much the price has climbed. In addition, even if we are correct in determining that
the price of a stock will decline, we run the risk of incorrectly determining when the decline will take
place. Short selling may not be appropriate in times of inflation, as prices may adjust upwards regardless
of the value of the stock.
Margin transactions: We will purchase stocks for your portfolio with money borrowed from your
brokerage account. This allows you to purchase more stock than you would be able to with your available
cash, and allows us to purchase stock without selling other holdings.
A risk in margin trading is that, in volatile markets, securities prices can fall very quickly. If the value
of the securities in your account minus what you owe the broker falls below a certain level, the broker
will issue a “margin call”, and you will be required to sell your position in the security purchased on
margin or add more cash to the account. In some circumstances, you may lose more money than you
originally invested.
Option trading: We use options as an investment tool. An option is a contract that gives the buyer the
right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an asset (such as a share of stock) at a specific price on or before
a certain date. An option, just like a stock or bond, is a security. An option is also a derivative, because
it derives its value from an underlying asset.
The two types of options are calls and puts:
A call gives us the right to buy an asset at a certain price within a specific period of time. We will buy a
call if we have determined that the stock will increase substantially before the option expires.
A put gives us the holder the right to sell an asset at a certain price within a specific period of time. We
will buy a put if we have determined that the price of the stock will fall before the option expires.
We will use options to speculate on the possibility of a sharp price swing. We will also use options to
10 | P ag e
“hedge” a purchase of the underlying security; in other words, we will use an option purchase to limit
the potential upside and downside of a security we have purchased for your portfolio.
We use “covered calls”, in which we sell an option on a security you own. In this strategy, you receive
a fee for making the option available, and the person purchasing the option has the right to buy the security
from you at an agreed-upon price.
A risk of covered calls is that the option buyer does not have to exercise the option, so that if we want to
sell the stock prior to the end of the option agreement, we have to buy the option back from the option
buyer, for a possible loss.
We use a “protective put” strategy in which we purchase puts on an underlying security (or a similar
security) to protect or hedge the possibility of the client position falling in value. This is useful when
clients own a large, concentrated position in a given security.
The risk of a protective put strategy is only the initial cost of the put at purchase which can be lost if the
put expires.
We use a “spreading strategy”, in which we purchase two or more option contracts (for example, a call
option that you buy and a call option that you sell) for the same underlying security. This effectively puts
you on both sides of the market, but with the ability to vary price, time and other factors.
A risk of spreading strategies is that the ability to fully profit from a price swing is limited.
Clients should understand that investing in any securities, including mutual funds, involves a risk of
loss of both income and principal that a client should be prepared to bear.
Item 9.
Disciplinary Information
Our firm has no reportable disciplinary events to disclose.
Item 10. Other Financial Industry Activities and Affiliations
Eric McDonald and Tyler Sturdivant are members of the General Partner that advises pooled investment
vehicles, MCM CCP/Baypine LP and the Islay Multifactor Fund I, LP.
Item 11. Code of Ethics, Participation in Client Transactions and Personal Trading
Code of Ethics Disclosure
Our firm has adopted a Code of Ethics which sets forth high ethical standards of business conduct that
we require of our employees, including compliance with applicable federal securities laws. Our Code of
Ethics includes policies and procedures for the review of quarterly securities transactions reports as well
as initial and annual securities holdings reports that must be submitted by the firm’s access persons.
Among other things, our Code of Ethics also requires the prior approval of any acquisition of securities
in a limited offering (e.g., private placement) or an initial public offering (“IPO”). Our code provides for
11 | P ag e
oversight, enforcement and recordkeeping provisions. A copy of our Code of Ethics is available to our
advisory clients and prospective clients upon request to the Client Services Manager, at the firm’s
principal office address.
Our firm, or individuals associated with our firm, may buy or sell securities identical to those
recommended to or purchased for customers for their personal accounts. In addition, any related
person(s) may have an interest or position in a certain security which may also be recommended to a
client. This practice results in a potential conflict of interest, as we may have an incentive to manipulate
the timing of such purchases to obtain a better price or more favorable allocation in rare cases of limited
availability.
To mitigate these potential conflicts of interest and ensure the fulfillment of our fiduciary responsibilities,
we have established the following restrictions:
1) All supervised persons, wherever appropriate, must either aggregate their trades with client trades OR
conduct their personal trading after clients if the employee trades on the same trading day
2) No principal or employee of our firm may buy or sell securities for their personal portfolio(s)
where their decision is substantially derived, in whole or in part, by reason of his or her
employment unless the information is also available to the investing public on reasonable
inquiry. No principal or employee of our firm may prefer his or her own interest to that of the
advisory client;
3) It is the expressed policy of our firm that no person employed by us may purchase or sell any
reportable security immediately prior to a transaction(s) being implemented for an advisory
account, and therefore, preventing such employees from benefiting from transactions placed on
behalf of advisory accounts;
4) In cases of partial order fills, clients receive first allocation priority;
5) We maintain a list of all securities holdings for our firm and anyone associated with this advisory
practice with access to advisory recommendations;
6) We emphasize the unrestricted right of the client to decline to implement any advice rendered,
except in situations where our firm is granted discretionary authority.
7) All of our principals and employees must act in accordance with all applicable Federal and State
regulations governing registered investment advisory practices.
8) Any individual not in observance of the above may be subject to disciplinary action or
termination.
Item 12. Brokerage Practices
We do not have any formal soft-dollar arrangements and do not contract with any broker dealer to
receive soft-dollar benefits. This means that we do not receive research or gain access to industry
analysts or conferences in return for paying higher commissions for client trades to a particular broker
12 | P ag e
dealer.
We do not request or accept the discretionary authority to determine the broker dealer to be used for
client accounts. Clients must direct us as to a broker dealer to be used for all client securities transactions.
In directing the use of a particular broker or dealer, it should be understood that we will not have authority
to negotiate commissions among various brokers, and best execution may not be achieved, resulting in
higher transaction costs for clients. For clients in need of brokerage or custodial services and depending
on client circumstances and needs, we may recommend the use of one of several broker dealers
(including, but not limited to Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. (hereinafter “Schwab”) and Fidelity
Brokerage Services, LLC (hereinafter, “Fidelity”)), provided that such recommendation is consistent
with our fiduciary duty to the client. Not all advisers require their clients to direct brokerage.
Our firm participates in the Fidelity Institutional Wealth Services Program (hereinafter, “FIWS”)
sponsored by Fidelity. Clients in need of brokerage and custodial services will have Fidelity
recommended to them. While there is no direct linkage between the investment advice given to clients
and our firm’s participation in the FIWS program, we receive economic benefits which would not be
received if we did not give investment advice to clients. These benefits include: A dedicated trading desk
that services FIWS participants exclusively, a dedicated service group and an account services manager
dedicated to our firm’s accounts, access to a real-time order matching system, ability to 'block' client
trades, electronic download of trades, balances and positions, access, for a fee, to an electronic interface
with FIWS' software, duplicate and batched client statements, confirmations and year-end summaries,
the ability to have advisory fees directly debited from client accounts (in accordance with federal and
state requirements), availability of third-party research and technology, a quarterly newsletter, access to
Fidelity mutual funds, access to “WealthCentral” (internet access to statements, confirmations and
transfer of asset status), access to Account View (through which clients may access their account
information over the internet via our website), access to over 350 mutual fund families and 4,500 mutual
funds NOT affiliated with Fidelity, of which over 2,000 have no transaction fee, ability to have loads
waived for our clients who invest in certain Fidelity loaded funds, when certain conditions are met and
maintained and the ability to have custody fees waived (when negotiated by the adviser and allowed
under certain circumstances).
The benefits we receive through participation in the FIWS program may depend upon the amount of
transactions directed to, or amount of assets custodied by, Fidelity.
Our firm also participates in the Schwab Institutional (SI) services program offered to independent
investment advisers by Schwab. Clients in need of brokerage and custodial services will have Schwab
recommended to them. As part of the SI program, our firm receives benefits that it would not receive if
it did not offer investment. These benefits include: receipt of duplicate client confirmations and bundled
duplicate statements; access to a trading desk serving SI participants exclusively; access to block trading
which provides the ability to aggregate securities transactions and then allocate the appropriate shares to
client accounts; ability to have investment advisory fees deducted directly from client account; access,
for a fee, to an electronic communication network for client order entry and account information; receipt
of compliance publications; and access to mutual funds which generally require significantly higher
minimum initial investments or are generally available only to institutional investors.
The benefits received through participation in the SI program may or may not depend upon the amount
of transactions directed to, or amount of assets custodied by, Schwab.
13 | P ag e
Participation in the FIWS and SI programs results a potential conflict of interest for our firm, as the
receipt of the above benefits creates an incentive for us to recommend Fidelity and Schwab.
Nonetheless, we have reviewed the services of Fidelity and Schwab and recommend their services based
on a number of factors. These factors include the professional services offered, commission rates, and
the custodial platform provided to clients. While, based on our business model, we will not seek to
exercise discretion to negotiate trades among various brokers on behalf of clients, we will, however,
periodically attempt to negotiate lower commission rates for our clients with Fidelity and Schwab.
Directed Brokerage
Clients may choose from either Schwab or Fidelity as their broker. McDonald does not currently have
the ability to work with clients who utilize other broker-dealers.
We reserve the right to decline acceptance of any client account for which the client directs the use of a
broker if we believe that this choice would hinder its fiduciary duty to the client and/or our ability to
service the account.
Prime Brokerage with Schwab and Fidelity
Clients are set-up with prime-brokerage relationships at Schwab and Fidelity. When clients have prime
brokerage arrangements, it allows us to place block trades at other brokerage firms for settlement at the
client’s custodial account. Clients benefit from trade aggregation which helps the firm with its best
execution obligations because clients receive the same price. Clients will pay a fee of $20 to $25 per
trade when we use other brokerage firms under this agreement. See fixed-income trades below for more
information.
Trade Aggregation
We may aggregate client trades when doing so is advantageous to our clients. Mostly, we will batch
client transactions to receive volume discounts and to obtain better and more uniform pricing across
client accounts. If we determine that aggregation of trades in a certain situation will be beneficial to our
clients, trades are sent to the broker with instructions to achieve VWAP (volume weighted average price).
Allocation is done pro-rata. Any exceptions from the pro-rata allocation procedure will be carefully
explained and documented. Such exceptions may occur due to varying cash availability across accounts,
divergent investment objectives and existing concentrations, and desire to avoid “odd lots,” (an amount
of a security that is less than the normal unit of trading for that particular security). For clients who are
custodied at Fidelity, the portfolio manager seeks to execute at VWAP to the best of their ability.
Trades are executed based on client objectives and model assignment, if any. For model-based accounts
trades are pre-allocated through our Tamarac Rebalancing Software and traded through the OMS FIX
connection at Schwab or sent directly to Fidelity’s unsent order page. Trades are blocked for each
security at the designated broker and allocated after execution.
For non-model or multi-strategy accounts, client objectives, risk tolerances and cash balances are
examined when a potential security is identified for purchase or sale. Often purchases or sales are block
traded at the custodian-level and allocated according to the client’s asset allocation. For partial fills,
14 | P ag e
shares are allocated pro-rata based on the pre-trade allocation worksheet, when applicable. Individual
non-block trades are usually associated with minor strategy adjustments or client requests.
Fixed Income Trades
McDonald utilizes two broker-dealers for fixed income trades; D.A. Davidson and Piper Sandler & Co.
This is often referred to as “trading away” and clients will incur additional trading costs when we use
Piper Sandler or D.A Davidson. The cost of trading away is $20 to $25 per trade. McDonald believes
that trading away fixed income trades helps achieve best execution because, among other things, it helps
to: minimize the risk of market movement in pricing, achieve competitive pricing, access additional
liquidity and investment sources and ensure that participating clients receive the same execution price.
McDonald performs a review of our fixed income trades bi-annually to review and document best
execution.
Item 13. Review of Accounts
Securities are continuously reviewed by the firm's Investment Team. This team is comprised of Principal
Portfolio Manager, Eric McDonald and Tyler Sturdivant, Securities Analyst and Associate Portfolio
Manager. Smaller mutual fund accounts are reviewed on a weekly basis for valuation purposes and on a
monthly basis for rebalancing and asset allocation changes. Larger accounts are reviewed on a weekly
basis for valuation purposes and cash reconciliation and monthly for asset allocation changes.
Underlying securities that make up the accounts are reviewed on a daily basis for changes in fundamental
and technical status.
Triggering factors for changes in account profiles include but are not limited to changes in: monetary
conditions, inflation expectations, government policy, company fundamentals, and investment company
management. In addition, many of our client accounts are managed on a tactical asset allocation model
that relies on several quantitative and fundamental factors (including those mentioned above). Modeled
accounts are rebalanced quarterly at a minimum or more frequently if our factors change substantially
inter-period. The Investment Team personally reviews each account for possible adjustments based on
established client objectives as stated in the client's investment policy statement or investment plan.
Clients are able to determine the depth of reporting they wish to receive. Clients are sent quarterly
portfolio appraisals by our firm that include historical cost, current market value, quantity of position
and name of security owned. Clients have the ability to request additional reports that include but are not
limited to: income and expense, realized gains/losses, performance percentages and changes in market
values. Clients may receive more frequent statements if so desired. Client reports are sent to clients as
soon as possible after each period.
Item 14. Client Referrals and Other Compensation
MCM currently does not have any referral arrangements in place.
Item 15. Custody
MCM does not have custody of client assets. However, under the current SEC rules, our firm is deemed
to have constructive custody of client assets because we directly debit client fees from their custodial
15 | P ag e
accounts. Therefore, we urge all of our management clients to carefully review and compare their quarterly
reviews of account holdings and/or performance results received from us to those they receive from their
custodian. Should you notice any discrepancies, please notify us and/or your custodian as soon as
possible.
In addition, because certain employees of the firm also act as the General Partner to the private funds,
the firm is deemed to have custody of the fund. The fund undergoes an annual surprise custody exam
by a PCAOB firm.
Item 16. Investment Discretion
For clients granting us discretionary authority to determine which securities and the amounts of securities
that are to be bought or sold for their account(s), we request that such authority be granted in writing,
typically in the executed advisory agreement. Should the client wish to impose reasonable limitations on
this discretionary authority, such limitations shall be included in this written authority statement. Clients
may change/amend these limitations as desired. Such amendments must be submitted to us by the client
in writing.
Item 17. Voting Client Securities
Advisory clients may elect to delegate their proxy voting authority to us. Alternatively, clients may, at
their election, choose to receive proxies related to their own accounts, in which case we may consult
with clients as requested. (With respect to ERISA accounts, we will vote proxies unless the plan
documents specifically reserve the plan sponsor’s right to vote proxies). To direct us to vote a proxy in
a particular manner, clients should contact the Client Services Manager, by telephone, electronic mail,
or in writing.
When we have discretion to vote proxies for our clients, we will vote those proxies with management,
unless there are compelling reasons not to do so, because confidence in management is one of the factors
we consider in making an investment. We believe this is in the best interests of its clients and in
accordance with our established policies and procedures. Our firm will retain all proxy voting books and
records for the requisite period of time, including a copy of each proxy statement received, a record of
each vote cast, a copy of any document created by us that was material to making a decision how to vote
proxies, and a copy of each written client request for information on how the adviser voted proxies. If
our firm has a conflict of interest in voting a particular action, we will notify the client of the conflict
and retain an independent third-party to cast a vote.
Clients may obtain a copy of our complete proxy voting policies and procedures by contacting the Client
Services Manager directly. Clients may request, in writing, information on how proxies for his/her shares
were voted. If any client requests a copy of our complete proxy policies and procedures or how we voted
proxies for his/her account(s), we will promptly provide such information to the client.
We will neither advise nor act on behalf of the client in legal proceedings involving companies whose
securities are held in the client’s account(s), including, but not limited to, the filing of “Proofs of Claim”
in class action settlements. If desired, clients may direct us to transmit copies of class action notices to
the client or a third party. Upon such direction, we will make commercially reasonable efforts to forward
such notices in a timely manner.
16 | P ag e
Item 18. Financial Information
Under no circumstances will we earn fees in excess of $1,200 more than six months in advance of
services rendered.
17 | P ag e
Part 2B of Form ADV: Brochure Supplement
Eric Craig McDonald
8001 Quaker Avenue
Suite J
Lubbock, TX 79424
Telephone: (806)744-8617
Islay Capital Management, LLC
dba McDonald Capital Management
8001 Quaker Avenue
Suite J
Lubbock, TX 79424
Telephone: (806)744-8617
02/20/2026
This brochure supplement provides information about Eric McDonald that supplements the McDonald
Capital Management brochure. You should have received a copy of that brochure. Please contact Eric
McDonald, Managing Member, and Chief Compliance Officer if you did not receive our brochure or if
you have any questions about the contents of this supplement.
18 | P ag e
Item 2.
Educational Background and Business Experience
Eric Craig McDonald, CFA
Year of Birth: 1963
Education:
Mr. McDonald graduated from the University of Texas at Austin, Texas with a B.B.A. degree in Finance
in 1985 and from Texas Tech University at Lubbock, Texas with an M.B.A. in Finance in 1987.
Business Background:
Managing Member, Chief Investment Officer Chief Compliance Officer, Islay Capital Management dba
McDonald Capital Management from 1990 to present. Mr. McDonald served on the Board of Trustees
of the Texas Teachers Retirement Fund (TRS) from April 2009 to September 2013. TRS is the largest
public retirement system in Texas in both membership and assets. Mr. McDonald completed his
appointment in September 2013 and is no longer obligated to oversight duties for the TRS system.
Professional Designations:
Mr. McDonald earned the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation in 1993. The CFA designation
is an international professional certification offered by the CFA Institute (formerly AIMR) to financial
analysts who complete a series of three examinations. To become a CFA charterholder candidates must
pass each of three six-hour exams, possess a bachelor's degree (or equivalent, as assessed by CFA
institute) and have 48 months of qualified, professional work experience. CFA charterholders are also
obligated to adhere to a strict Code of Ethics and Standards governing their professional conduct.
Item 3.
Disciplinary Information
Mr. McDonald does not have any history of reportable disciplinary events.
Item 4.
Other Business Activities
Mr. McDonald serves as a board member of the Lubbock Firefighters Pension Board. This is an unpaid
position. Mr. McDonald serves as the General Partner to the two private funds advised by McDonald
Capital Management.
Item 5.
Additional Compensation
Mr. McDonald does not receive any additional compensation from third parties for providing investment
advice to its clients and does not compensate anyone for client referrals.
Item 6.
Supervision
As the Managing Member and Chief Compliance Officer of MCM, Eric McDonald is responsible for all
employee supervision and general business strategy of the firm. He can be reached at (806) 744-8617.
19 | P ag e
Mr. McDonald is also responsible for formulation and monitoring of investment advice offered to client
documenting investment meeting deliberations, overseeing all material investment policy changes,
conducting periodic testing to ensure that client objectives and mandates are being met and the
implementation and monitoring of our compliance program, including the collection and review of all
employee personal securities transactions on a quarterly basis.
20 | P ag e
Part 2B of Form ADV: Brochure Supplement
Tyler Sturdivant, CFA
8001 Quaker Avenue Suite J
Lubbock, TX 79424
Telephone: (806)744-8617
Islay Capital Management, LLC
dba McDonald Capital Management
8001 Quaker Avenue
Suite J
Lubbock, TX 79424
Telephone: (806)744-8617
02/20/2026
This brochure supplement provides information about Tyler Sturdivant that supplements the McDonald
Capital Management brochure. You should have received a copy of that brochure. Please contact Eric
McDonald, Managing Member and Chief Compliance Officer if you did not receive our brochure or if you
have any questions about the contents of this supplement.
21 | P ag e
Item 2.
Educational Background and Business Experience
Tyler Sturdivant
Year of Birth: 1994
Education:
Mr. Sturdivant graduated with a B.B.A. in Finance from Texas Tech University in August 2017.
Business Background:
Associate Portfolio Manager and Trader at McDonald Capital Management 2017-Present
Professional Designations:
Mr. Sturdivant earned the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation in 2020. The CFA designation
is an international professional certification offered by the CFA Institute (formerly AIMR) to financial
analysts who complete a series of three examinations. To become a CFA charterholder candidates must
pass each of three six-hour exams, possess a bachelor's degree (or equivalent, as assessed by CFA
institute) and have 48 months of qualified, professional work experience. CFA charterholders are also
obligated to adhere to a strict Code of Ethics and Standards governing their professional conduct.
Disciplinary Information
Item 3.
Mr. Sturdivant does not have any history of reportable disciplinary events.
Other Business Activities
Item 4.
Mr. Sturdivant teaches as an adjunct professor once per week for the Texas Tech Student Managed
Investment Fund class. He may spend up to <5% of his time on this non-advisory activity. Mr.
Sturdivant serves as the General Partner to the two private funds advised by McDonald Capital
Management. Mr. Sturdivant owns a 9% equity stake with Axiom Acquisition Group for conducting
valuation reviews.
Item 5.
Additional Compensation
Mr. Sturdivant does not receive any additional compensation from third parties for providing investment
advice to its clients and does not compensate anyone for client referrals.
Item 6.
Supervision
As the Managing Member and Chief Compliance Officer of MCM, Eric McDonald is responsible for all
employee supervision and general business strategy of the firm. He can be reached at (806) 744-8617.
Mr. McDonald is also responsible for formulation and monitoring of investment advice offered to client,
documenting investment meeting deliberations, overseeing all material investment policy changes,
conducting periodic testing to ensure that client objectives and mandates are being met and the
implementation and monitoring of our compliance program, including the collection and review of all
employee personal securities transactions on a quarterly basis.
22 | P ag e