← Back to First Affirmative Financial Network LLC profile
GOLDMAN SACHS WRAP FEE BROCHURE APPENDIX 1A
First Affirmative Financial Network LLC (CRD 109036), brochure dated April 17, 2026. Text extracted from the firm's SEC Form ADV Part 2 brochure.
View firm on SEC ↗ · Current Form ADV (PDF) ↗
Form ADV Part 2A – Appendix 1A
April 17, 2026
Goldman Sachs Advisor Solutions Wrap Fee Brochure for
Clients and Prospective Clients of First Affirmative Financial
Network, LLC DBA Formative
Item 1: Introduction and Overview
This Wrap Fee Brochure provides information about the qualifications and business practices of
First Affirmative Financial Network, LLC DBA Formative (“Formative”). Capitalized terms not
defined in this Wrap Fee Brochure are defined in Formative’s Form ADV Part 2A (Disclosure
Brochure).
Formative is an independent, employee-owned, and managed investment advisor registered
(RIA) with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) with its principal place of
business at 5475 Mark Dabling Boulevard, Suite 320, Colorado Springs, CO 80918. The fact that
Formative is registered with the SEC should not be read as an endorsement of Formative or that
Formative has a certain level or training.
This Wrap Fee Brochure is required to be delivered to any prospective client of the Formative
sponsored wrap fee program involving Goldman Sachs Advisor Solutions (Goldman Sachs) prior
to or at the time of entering into an investment advisory relationship with Formative that
includes participation in the Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program.) Formative also sponsors a
wrap fee program involving Orion Portfolio Solutions, (OPS) (OPS Wrap Fee Program) and Apex
Clearing, Inc. (Apex) (Apex Wrap Fee Program.) A separate Wrap Fee Brochure is available for
clients whose investment advisory relationship with Formative includes participation in the OPS
Wrap Fee Program and/or the Apex Wrap Fee Program. An electronic copy is available on a
publicly accessible area on the Formative website www.firstaffirmative.com.
Additional information about Formative is available on the SEC’s website at
www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. You can search the SEC’s website for information about an RIA by
using the RIA’s unique identifying number known as a “CRD number.” Formative’s CRD number
is 109036. You can also access an electronic copy of this document in a publicly accessible area
on the Formative website www.firstaffirmative.com.
If you have any questions about the contents of this Wrap Fee Brochure, please contact
Formative’s Chief Compliance Officer, Kathy Lewis, at 719-660-6157 or
kathylewis@firstaffirmative.com. While submitted to the SEC, the information in this Wrap
Fee Brochure has not been approved or verified by the SEC or by any state securities authority.
Item 2: Material Changes
Consistent with SEC rules, Formative updates this Wrap Fee Brochure at least annually, within
90 days of the close of its fiscal year, which is December 31. If there are material changes from
the prior annual update of this Wrap Fee Brochure (and you received a prior version of this
Wrap Fee Brochure), such changes will be set forth in the “Summary of Material Changes”
accompanying this Wrap Fee Brochure.
Item 4: Services, Fees, and Compensation
Description of the Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program
Goldman Sachs Advisor Solutions (Goldman Sachs) and Folio Investments, Inc. (Folio) are
Goldman Sachs Companies. The Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program applies to discretionary
investment advisory services offered by Formative, through its Network Advisors or
Solicitors/Endorsers (as defined in the Disclosure Brochure), consistent with its Sustainable
Investment Solutions advisory offering (as described in the Disclosure Brochure). Formative
serves as a Multi-Manager Account Manager (MLT) a Managed Mutual Fund (MMF) Account
Manager, and the Account Manager for Values Aligned Direct Index Solutions (VADIS) accounts
described below. As a MLT Account Manager, Formative may use proprietary investment model
portfolios constructed and managed by Formative (Proprietary Models) as well as models
selected by Formative that are constructed and managed by third- party unaffiliated
investment advisors (Third-Party Models). As a MMF Account Manager with respect to
accounts custodied at Goldman Sachs, Formative only recommends Proprietary Models to
clients.
An example of our billing method can be found in the Disclosure Brochure.
Wrap Fee for the Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program - Fiduciary
The Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program fee includes all costs for investment management, trade
execution, and custody and clearing, unless specifically noted as a separate charge below. Fees
on assets included in the Wrap Fee Program are charged as a percentage of assets under
management, annualized, in arrears, using the average daily balance calculation method. Fees
are charged quarterly according to the schedule below. Fees for services provided by Network
Advisors or Solicitors/Endorsers are in addition to the fees presented below and will be
collected along with the Formative fees as described below as part of the wrap fee.
Tiers
Cumulative
(For Internal
Use)
Formative:
Discretionary
Investment
YourStake:
Impact
Preferences
Goldman
Sachs:
Custody
Goldman
Sachs:
Model
Advisory
Services
&
Clearing
2,000,000
2,000,000
0.31%
Platform
(Required
for VADIS)
0.05%
0.09%
Manager
fees as
applicable
0.35%
8,000,000
10,000,000
0.26%
0.05%
0.09%
0.35%
10,000,000 20,000,000
0.21%
0.05%
0.09%
0.35%
On the
First
On the
Next
On the
Next
Above
20,000,000
0.21%
0.05%
0.09%
0.35%
Third-Party Model Managers (also referred to as portfolio managers) utilized by Formative
when advising a Multi-Manager Account are paid a portion of the maximum fee shown above.
Proprietary Models are also available to Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers to provide
discretionary investment advice to clients on the Goldman Sachs platform. When a Proprietary
Model is used in a Multi-Manager Account by a Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser,
Formative is paid as the Model Manager. The same methodology for determining which Model
Manager to use for any client account is not influenced by, or biased toward, Proprietary
Models.
New accounts are subject to the following minimums:
Managed Mutual Fund Accounts:
Multi-Manager Accounts:
$ 50,000
$ 50,000
The account minimums are negotiable on a case-by-case basis and are dependent on a variety
of factors, including but not limited to other accounts in a client household (adults who all live
at the same address who have investment accounts with Formative). Accounts billed for the
same program at Goldman Sachs will be grouped together for breakpoints unless such grouping
is prohibited by regulatory rule or Internal Revenue Service (IRS) restrictions.
The Wrap Fee may be more or less than the aggregate fee for services if they were offered
separately. Some factors that may contribute to the relative cost differential include, but are
not limited to, the brokerage and clearing costs, commissions based on trading frequency or
commissions based on type of security (e.g., mutual fund or ETF versus single stock), and the
mutual fund share classes that may be available.
Additional information regarding the billing process is available in the Disclosure Brochure.
Mutual Fund Expenses
Mutual funds have internal expenses, such as portfolio management, legal and accounting,
printing, marketing, trading costs and other administrative expenses, including fees paid to
custodians. Fund expenses are more fully disclosed in each mutual fund prospectus. They are
accounted for and charged internally by the mutual funds and monies collected or retained are
not shared with Formative, any affiliate of Formative or any Network Advisor or
Solicitor/Endorser.
Any mutual fund sale within a defined period of time may, per the mutual fund prospectus,
after the initial purchase may trigger a contingent deferred sales charge by the mutual fund
company on the transaction. These charges vary among the mutual funds that are held in a
client account.
Compensation for Accounts Under Title I of the Employee Retirement Income
Security Act (ERISA)
Clients should be aware that conflicts of interest surrounding compensation may impair the
objectivity of Formative and its owners, officers, investment advisor representatives, or
employees when providing advisory services. This includes a recommendation to rollover
retirement assets to an account managed by the advisor. The Department of Labor’s Rule 3.0,
known as the Fiduciary Rule, requires investment fiduciaries to review the costs associated with
rolling over ERISA plan assets to another retirement vehicle. A conflict of interest occurs if the
advisor earns a new fee or increases its current compensation as a result of the rollover. There
also is the possibility of conflicts of interest between clients and any Network Advisor if the
service is provided for variable compensation. Formative offers fee-based compensation which
tends to reduce or change the possibility of conflicts of interest but cannot eliminate them
entirely. Formative always offers advice that is in the best interest of the client. It is the client’s
responsibility to evaluate that advice and determine if it is appropriate before acting. No client
is obligated to accept any recommendation, including recommendations regarding rollovers,
and all clients are free to implement any recommendation with the broker, planner, or advisor
of their choice.
Mutual Fund Company Payments to Custodians
Rule 12b-1 fees are defined as annual marketing or distribution fees on mutual funds. These
expenses are included in the fund’s expense ratio and are in some cases shared with
custodians. Formative may place trades in mutual funds that pay compensation to custodians.
12b-1 fees paid to custodians are not shared with Formative.
As part of Formative’s fiduciary duty, we will evaluate the costs associated with mutual funds to
determine which fund, or share class of a fund, is most suitable for client portfolios. If
appropriate, Formative will exchange share classes to a less expensive share class. In taxable
accounts, these exchanges will be done, when possible, with the fund companies as tax-free
exchanges.
Additional Goldman Sachs Fees
Transaction-Based Pricing
Non-retirement accounts will be charged on a per transaction basis when the security to be
bought or sold is ineligible for trading in Folio’s patented window trade process. In such
circumstances, your order will be routed and executed as a direct trade and charged the
following fees.
Telephone
Internet
$45.00 per trade
$3.95 per trade
Goldman Sachs also will charge the account transaction fees based on the above schedule if
securities are transferred into a non-retirement account and need to be sold to implement a
client’s new investment strategy.
Fees Upon Termination of Services
Goldman Sachs may charge a termination or transfer-out fee, that may change from time to
time. This fee is determined by Goldman Sachs and the monies received are not shared with
Formative.
Mutual Fund Transaction Commissions Charged to Clients
Some mutual funds that are included in client investment portfolios offer different types of
shares, known as “share classes.” Each share class has different shareholder services and/or
distribution arrangements with different fees and expenses and, therefore, different
performance results. For example, class A shares, also called “retail shares”, usually have a
front-end load or charge (commission) which is paid to the custodial BD when the mutual fund
is purchased. Institutional class shares, in contrast, generally are available only to institutional
investors and may have very different fees and expenses from class A shares, but generally do
not require front-end commissions. See the SEC website, the Financial Industry Regulatory
Authority website or the relevant mutual fund share prospectus for additional information
regarding share classes.
Formative generally uses only institutional class shares with no front-end loads in the Managed
Mutual Fund Accounts custodied with Goldman Sachs and, to the extent it does use a mutual
fund that typically has a front-end load, Formative will do so only if the front-end load is
waived. There is no transaction fee charged to clients for purchasing mutual fund shares at
Goldman Sachs.
Incidental Fees
In addition to the fees above, clients are still responsible for any special fees incurred at the
client’s request, such as wire transfer fees, or account maintenance fees, which are charged
and disclosed by Goldman Sachs. Such fees are subject to change and can be found at:
https://www.folioinstitutional.com/resources/service-fees.jsp
Margin
Goldman Sachs margin accounts are not available.
Costs for Third-Party Services
Goldman Sachs passes through the costs from third parties, including, but not limited to, the
following:
• Services provided by broker dealers other than Goldman Sachs
• SEC and securities exchange fees
• Transfer taxes
• Fees for odd lot differentials
• Mutual fund short-term redemption fees; and
• Other similar costs and charges.
Compensation to Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers relating to Client
Participation in the Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program
Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers are compensated from the Wrap Fee. The amount
of this compensation may be more or less than the compensation the Network Advisor or
Solicitors/Endorsers may receive if not recommending, or introducing the client to, the
Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program. This may create a conflict of interest in that the Network
Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser may have a financial incentive to recommend the Goldman Sachs
Wrap Fee Program over other programs and services.
Indirect Compensation Specific to Custodians. Formative is charged an annual fee per client
account to Orion Advisor Technology (OAT) for their Astro platform. This technology allows us
to design, implement, and reoptimize portfolios. Formative employs this technology for
accounts held at each of our approved custodians. Apex Clearing pays OAT a fee for each
account opened on their platform. The fees charged to the Client for Formative services are the
same for each platform except OPS.
Item 5: Account Requirements and Types of Clients
Formative does not accept clients under any restriction relating to the USA Patriot Act or Bank
Secrecy Act or comparable legislation.
The minimums for wrap fee accounts at Goldman Sachs are:
Managed Mutual Fund Accounts:
Multi-Manager Accounts:
$ 50,000
$ 50,000
These minimums are negotiable on a case-by-case basis and are dependent on a variety of
factors, including but not limited to other accounts in a client household (adults who all live at
the same address who have investment accounts with Formative).
The following types of clients may participate in the Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program:
Individuals (to include high net worth individuals)
•
• Trusts, estates, and charitable organizations
• Nonprofit organizations and other non-governmental organizations
• Corporations or other businesses not listed above
Item 6: Portfolio Manager Selection and Evaluation
Selection of Models
Use of Proprietary Models
As noted above, Formative makes available Proprietary Models on the Goldman Sachs Platform
that may be used by Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers in the process of providing
investment advisory services in the Goldman Sachs Wrap Fee Program. Formative retains the
portion of the revenues allocated for compensation to model managers. Formative’s models
are reviewed in the same manner as outside models and are included only if the model is
suitable for the client portfolio. In some cases, the Formative models are the only models
available for a particular asset class or, in the case of fossil fuel free models.
One IAR is a member of Formative senior management and the Investment Committee. In his
role, he provides investment advisory services to individual clients, while also working on
developing Proprietary Models. Proprietary Models developed by this IAR are subject to the
same selection and review process as other Third- Party Models and other Proprietary Models.
Further, he does not receive compensation relating to the Proprietary Model’s development.
Formative’s Advisory Business - Fiduciary
Formative provides investment advice consistent with the philosophies of values-aligned
investing. Clients who choose to invest with Formative make a conscious choice to put their
money to work for a dual purpose—to provide for a secure retirement, for example, while
working for a better, more socially just, and environmentally sustainable future for all.
Through Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers (as defined in the Disclosure Brochure)
Formative provides discretionary investment advisory services to investors, tailored to the
individual needs of the client, that integrate values-based criteria into the investment analysis
process according to the clients’ preference. Formative can create portfolios, using mutual
funds, and/or individual securities such as stocks, bonds, exchange traded funds (ETFs),
exchange traded notes (ETNs), real estate investment trusts (REITs), American depository
receipts (ADRs), government agency or Treasury securities, corporate or municipal bonds,
certificates of deposit (CODs), commercial paper or other securities. The different investment
programs offered by Formative may not all offer the ability to invest in all the securities listed
above. Formative does not offer discretionary investment advisory services concerning direct
ownership of commodities, futures, derivatives, or short selling.
Discretionary Investment Advisory Services – Sustainable Investment Solutions
in Practice
Discretionary Investment Advice
Through its Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers, Formative creates unique relationships
with clients by combining discretionary investment advisory services and advanced financial
technologies with responsible investment strategies that consider a client’s values. Generally,
Formative’s innovative approach combines:
Fiduciary Responsibility. In Formative’s relationship with clients where Formative is providing
discretionary investment advice, Formative acknowledges that it serves and acts in a fiduciary
capacity under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940.
When we provide investment advice to you regarding your retirement plan account or a type of
individual retirement account (IRA), we are fiduciaries within the meaning of Title I of the
Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and/or the Internal Revenue Code, as
applicable, which are laws governing retirement accounts. We also act as fiduciaries when
recommending a rollover of retirement plans. For more information, please see the ADV
Disclosure Brochure. The way we make money creates some conflicts with your interests.
Under both rules Formative and the Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers that we work
with operate in your best interest and do not place their needs ahead of yours.
The types of rollovers include an existing Retirement Plan to an IRA; an existing IRA to a
Retirement Plan; an employer Retirement Plan to a new employer Retirement Plan; an IRA to
an IRA; and a change from one retirement account type to another type, including from
commission billing to fees.
Individualized Advice. One size does not fit all. Formative offers a variety of fee-based
investment options, each designed to best meet the needs of individual clients and/or specific
types of clients. The client can place reasonable restrictions on the types of investments to be
held in the client account.
Objectivity. Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers provide their clients with objective
advice. Fees for account management are generally based on assets under management and, as
a result, the client’s interests, the interests of the Network Advisor, Solicitor/Endorser, and the
interests of Formative are closely aligned.
Wrap Fee Program Participation
Formative sponsors discretionary advisory services where advisory fees and other fees are
bundled together with other costs whcih can include the cost of executing trades in your
account which are charged to your account as one "wrap fee".
Formative participates in a wrap fee program – sponsored by Geneos Wealth Management,
Inc., (Axiom) by making its Proprietary Models available on the platform. The Proprietary
Models on the Axiom platform are required to meet certain criteria set by Axiom and any
models listed are subject to ongoing reviews. Formative constructs such models with the same
investment philosophy and process as it uses in other Proprietary Models. However, the
included securities are restricted to securities approved by Axiom and consistent with Axiom’s
asset allocation strategies and model construction guidelines. Formative exercises no discretion
with respect to clients subscribed to the model portfolios but may receive an asset-based fee
when a model constructed by Formative is used by Axiom or a representative of Axiom in
making a recommendation to a client.
Retirement Plan Consulting Services
Formative may offer the services listed below to individuals and charitable organizations who
need assistance with pension, profit sharing, and 401(k) plans for an hourly or one-time fee.
This assistance will be reviewed against the Five Part Test developed by the Department of
Labor to determine if it rises to the status of fiduciary advice. The DOL Fiduciary Rule
requirements will be met, if applicable. The services are limited to the following non-
discretionary consulting services:
• Education about investment vehicles for the plan trustees; and
• Provision of educational support and investment workshops to self-directed 401(k)
plans participants.
Formative does not provide investment advisory services to participants in retirement plans
where it provides services to the plan.
Formative is compensated for its retirement plan consulting services either based on an hourly
rate as negotiated between Formative and the plan sponsor or a fee charged based upon assets
under advisement by the asset custodian.
Formative’s Advisory Business – Non-Fiduciary
Formative provides non-fiduciary services to selling, see below. Upon receipt of authorization
signed by the client allowing Formative access to their accounts at the requisite custodian we
will:
1. Facilitate the opening of client accounts
2. Complete a quantitative review of Mutual Funds and Model Managers in Formative’s
Sustainable Investment Universe
3. Trade accounts on a non-discretionary basis upon instruction from advisors and/or
clients under limited circumstances
4. Collect fees from client accounts based on the schedule agreed upon by the client and
the selling agent
5. Vote client proxies if authorized; and,
6. Retain an agreed upon amount and distribute the fees to the selling agent and any
money manager or sub-advisor managing the account. Formative may act as a money
manager for part of the client’s account on Goldman Sachs for which it will also be
compensated.
Non-Fiduciary Fee Schedule
Tiers
Formative Non-
Fiduciary Fee
$100,000
0.25%
Goldman Sachs
Custody and
Clearing
0.09%
Goldman Sachs
Model Manager
fees as applicable
0.35%
$100,000
0.25%
0.09%
0.35%
$1,800,000
0.25%
0.09%
0.35%
$8,000,000
0.20%
0.09%
0.35%
$10,000,000
0.15%
0.09%
0.35%
On the
first
On the
next
On the
next
On the
next
On the
next
Above
$20,000,000
0.15%
0.09%
0.35%
Performance-Based Fees
Formative does not charge performance-based fees.
Methods of Analysis, Investment Strategies, Risk of Loss
Investment Philosophy
Formative follows an established investment management process consistent with standards of
fiduciary care and with long-term orientation.
Formative’s experience suggests that the financial planning and investment needs of most
socially conscious investors can be met while providing competitive investment returns without
a material increase in risk. For most clients, Formative believes that a long-term, diversified
approach is the most appropriate investment strategy. First, Affirmative supports strategic
asset allocation and more active portfolio management strategies. Formative does not offer
recommendations concerning direct ownership of commodities, futures, derivatives, or short
selling, but does offer tactical investment strategies appropriate for some investors. Formative
may use the following types of investment vehicles in the service of achieving client goals and
objectives.
• American depository receipts (ADRs)
• Certificates of deposit
• Commercial paper
• Corporate bonds
• Exchange traded funds (ETFs)
• Exchange traded notes (ETNs)
• Government agency securities
•
Individual stocks
• Municipal bonds
• Mutual funds
• Options on equities
• OTC securities
• Other exchange traded securities
• Private placements
• Real estate investment trusts (REITs)
• Warrants
Methods of Analysis
Formative may use the following forms of analysis in formulating investment advice and/or
managing client assets:
Asset Allocation. Rather than focusing primarily on securities selection, Formative attempts to
identify an appropriate ratio of equities and fixed income, and cash suitable to the client’s
investment goals and risk tolerance. A risk of asset allocation is that the client may not
participate in sharp increases in a particular security, industry, or market sector if it is not
included in their allocation. Another risk is that the ratio of equities and fixed income, and cash,
will change over time due to stock and market movements and, if not corrected, will no longer
be appropriate for the client’s goals.
Charting. In this type of technical analysis, charts of market and security activity are reviewed in
an attempt to identify when the market is moving up or down, to predict how long the trend
may last, and when that trend might reverse. While this is a common method of analysis, there
is always the risk that past performance is not representative of future results or that the
assumptions made prove to be incorrect.
Cyclical Analysis. In this type of technical analysis, the movements of a particular stock against
the overall market are analyzed to predict the price movement of the security. There always is
the risk that past performance is not representative of future results or that the assumptions
made prove to be incorrect.
Fundamental Analysis. The intrinsic value of a security is analyzed by reviewing economic and
financial factors (including the overall economy, industry conditions, and the financial condition
and management of the company itself) to determine if the company is underpriced
(suggesting it may be a good time to buy) or overpriced (suggesting it may be a good time to
sell). Fundamental analysis does not attempt to anticipate market movements or changes in
value. There is risk in the fact that the price of a security can rise or fall along with the overall
market, regardless of the economic and financial factors considered in evaluating the stock.
Mutual Fund and/or ETF Due Diligence. Formative’s Mutual Fund and Multi-Manager Model
formation process incorporates the objectivity of quantitative analysis and the insights of
fundamental research. This two-pronged approach begins with our proprietary Mutual and
Model Fund Scores, which encompass both financial and sustainability factors.
Formative utilizes these Scores as the foundation for in-depth manager reviews. In one-on-one
conversations, we assess individual managers to ensure their investments are aligned with our
and our clients’ personal values, social priorities, and mission. We do this by analyzing the firm,
portfolio management and research teams, investment process, and our values-based
integration methodology, as well as proxy voting, corporate actions, and engagement.
Finally, we construct well-diversified portfolios designed to deliver risk-adjusted returns to
enable investors to achieve their financial goals. We diversify – across asset classes,
geographies, sectors, styles, and market capitalizations – to mitigate risk. Well-diversified and
structurally sound, our values-aligned Sustainable Investment Solutions are constructed with
the probability of enabling our clients to achieve their investment objectives. Fiduciary duty is
at the heart of our investment philosophy.
Qualitative Analysis. This type of analysis describes the process of evaluating difficult to
quantify factors such as quality of management, labor relations, and strength of research and
development factors not readily subject to measurement and predict changes to share price
based on that data. A risk in using qualitative analysis is that our subjective judgment may
prove incorrect.
Quantitative Analysis. Mathematical modeling is used in an attempt to obtain more accurate
measurements of a company’s quantifiable data, such as the value of a share price or earnings
per share and predict changes to that data. A risk in using quantitative analysis is that the
models used may be based on assumptions that prove to be incorrect.
Risks for all Forms of Analysis and Due Diligence. Formative’s securities analysis methods rely
on the assumption that the companies whose securities Formative purchases and sells, the
rating agencies that review these securities, and other publicly available sources of information
about these securities, are providing accurate and unbiased data. While Formative is alert to
indications that data may be incorrect, there is always a risk that analysis may be compromised
by inaccurate or misleading information.
Technical Analysis. Historical market movements are analyzed, and that analysis is applied to
the present to recognize recurring patterns of investor behavior and predict future price
movement. Technical analysis does not consider the underlying financial condition of a
company. Risk is inherent in a poorly managed or financially unsound company
underperforming regardless of market movement.
Third-Party Model Manager and/or Sub-Advisor Due Diligence. Formative examines the
experience, expertise, investment philosophies, and past performance of independent Third-
Party Model Managers and/or Sub-Advisors in an attempt to determine if there has been
demonstrated ability to invest over a period of time and in different economic conditions.
Formative monitors the Third-Party Model Manager’s model holdings, strategies,
concentrations, and leverage as part of its overall periodic risk assessment. Additionally, as part
of Formative’s due-diligence process, it surveys a Third-Party Model Manager’s or Sub-Advisor’s
compliance and business enterprise risks.
A risk of investing using Third-Party Model Manager and/or Sub-Advisors who have been
successful in the past is that they may not be able to replicate that success in the future. In
addition, as Formative does not control the underlying investments in a Third-Party Model
Manager’s portfolio, there is also a risk that a manager may deviate from the stated investment
mandate or strategy of the portfolio, making it a less suitable investment for clients. Moreover,
as Formative does not control the manager’s daily business and compliance operations,
Formative may be unaware of the lack of internal controls necessary to prevent business,
regulatory, or reputational deficiencies.
Values-Aligned Direct Index Solution (VADIS). VADIS attempts to replicate the performance of
an index by purchasing the underlying individual equities instead of using an ETF or mutual fund
in an investor’s portfolio. Formative’s portfolio construction expertise and discretionary
investment advisory services may be implemented using our carefully vetted Impact
Preferences, or combined with YourStake’s values-aligned client assessment, data collection
and organization, analytics, and reporting capabilities for investors who seek alignment of
personal values factors into investment portfolios that attempt to replicate the performance of
a chosen benchmark in our Values Aligned Direct Index Solution.
Our VADIS Portfolios are constructed on the Orion Astro platform using client-specific inputs
provided by the investment advisor. These inputs include but are not limited to:
•
Impact Preferences, which may include individual or lists of companies chosen by the
client for exclusion or inclusion in the portfolio
Investment strategy constraints and client preferences, such as:
• A desired benchmark, which may be a standard index or combination thereof
•
• Maximum number of securities
• Desired tracking error, security count, and security exposure
• Turnover, and trade thresholds, size, and number
• Existing legacy positions, specific-company inclusions/exclusions; and
• Tax considerations
Values-Aligned Integration. A sustainable and responsible approach to investing includes both
quantitative and qualitative analysis. Our investment process integrates analysis of in the
client’s values into the portfolio design. Management values factors can have a material
influence (either positive or negative) on company profitability, value, and share price. Risk is
inherent in the fact that a poorly managed or financially unsound company or product may
cause the investment to underperform regardless of its mission.
Investment Strategies
Formative may use the following strategies in managing client accounts, provided that such
strategies are appropriate to the needs of the client and consistent with the client’s investment
objectives, risk tolerance, and time horizons, among other considerations:
Illiquid Securities. Formative may, from time to time, assist clients with analyzing investments
in securities in the areas of unlisted and/or unregistered debt or equity (commonly referred to
as “private placements”), which have no current or anticipated liquidity. Formative will provide
investment advice on such securities that have been approved by its due diligence and
investment approval processes. When analyzing investments in securities of this type,
Formative will use the following analysis: fundamental, qualitative, quantitative and risk.
Long-Term Purchases. Formative may purchase securities with the intention of holding them in
the client’s account for a year or longer. Typically, this strategy is employed when:
• Formative believes the securities to be currently undervalued, and/or
• Formative wants exposure to a particular asset class over time, regardless of the current
projection for this class.
A risk in a long-term purchase strategy is that by holding the security for this length of time,
Formative may not take advantage of short-term gains that could be profitable to a client.
Moreover, if Formative’s predictions are incorrect, a security may decline sharply in value
before the decision is made to sell.
Short-Term Purchases. When utilizing this strategy, Formative may purchase securities with the
idea of selling them within a relatively short time (typically a year or less). Formative does this
to take advantage of conditions it believes will soon result in a price swing in the securities
purchased.
A short-term purchase strategy poses risks should the anticipated price swing not materialize;
Formative is then left with the option of having a long-term investment in a security that was
designed to be a short-term purchase, or potentially taking a loss. In addition, this strategy
involves more frequent trading than does a longer-term strategy; and may result in increased
brokerage and other transaction-related costs, as well as less favorable tax treatment of short-
term capital gains.
Risk of Loss
Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Each client of Formative must be prepared to
bear the risk of loss with respect to each account established.
Proxy Voting
Owners of company stock and mutual fund shares have a right to be heard on matters put
before shareholders for a vote. Shareholder voting is the primary means by which shareholders
can influence a company or mutual fund’s operations, its corporate governance, and other
activities that may fall outside of financial considerations.
You have provided Formative discretion in managing your accounts, we will vote your proxies
consistent with our Proxy Voting Guidelines, except in the circumstances described below or if
you instruct us that you do not wish for Formative to vote your proxies.
You are provided with a copy of Formative’s Proxy Voting Guidelines at the time you open your
account with us and annually thereafter. These guidelines also are always available on our
website and upon request as described below. We believe one of the reasons you have chosen
Formative to provide you advisory services is our commitment to socially responsible investing,
which includes voting proxies consistent with this philosophy, as is reflected in our Proxy Voting
Guidelines. Therefore, you must notify us in writing and instruct us how you would like us to
vote your proxies if you do not want them voted as described in the Proxy Voting Guidelines.
To assist with proxy voting, Formative has an arrangement with an independent governance
analysis and proxy voting firm to provide research to Formative and to vote proxies based on
Formative’s Proxy Voting Guidelines The independent third-party firm will vote all holdings in
which Formative clients have a material interest, defined as all shares held at Schwab, Goldman
Sachs, SEI, and Apex. Formative does not vote proxies at any other custodians.
As described above, client proxies voting is based on social responsibility concerns and financial
considerations, as reflected in the Proxy Voting Guidelines, updated at least annually. The
independent third-party proxy voting service discloses to Formative, at least annually, potential
conflicts of interest between their research/proxy voting services and their corporate
governance consulting services and their procedures for limiting such conflicts.
Clients should be aware that they are under no obligation to assign proxy voting duties to
Formative. Clients may choose from proxy voting options that are offered by their custodian.
For example, accounts held at Goldman Sachs offer a client has the right at any time, even if
proxy voting has been delegated to Formative, to vote any individual proxy themselves and
override any vote that may be cast by the proxy voting service hired by Formative.
Clients of advisors using our non-fiduciary services can opt-in to our proxy voting services by
requesting such on the authorization form allowing access to Formative. If the client does not
authorize Formative to vote their proxies at Goldman Sachs, they must vote their own proxies
by logging into their Goldman Sachs account. Any proxies voted by Formative can be overridden
by the client.
Clients may obtain a copy of Formative’s Proxy Voting Guidelines by visiting the Formative
website (www.firstaffirmative.com), sending an email to service@firstaffirmative.com or
proxyvoting@firstaffirmative.com, or by sending a request in writing to the address listed on
the cover page of this document. Clients may request information on how proxies for his/her
shares were voted and Formative will promptly provide such information to the client.
With respect to ERISA accounts, Formative will vote proxies if granted that authority unless the
plan documents specifically reserve the plan sponsor’s right to vote proxies. To direct Formative
to vote a proxy in a particular manner, clients should send an email to
proxyvoting@firstaffirmative.com.
Formative does not vote proxies for the following types of accounts:
• Accounts held in custody by Schwab that have not granted Formative authority to vote
proxies
• ERISA accounts that specifically require the plan sponsor to vote the proxies
• Accounts that participate in the OPS Wrap Fee Program; and
In situations where Formative does not vote proxies, proxy documents are accessible by logging
into the Goldman Sachs website for advised clients, www.folioinstutional.com. Upon request,
Formative and its IARs may provide information about proxy issues to clients who have chosen
to vote their own proxies.
Clients can instruct Formative to vote proxies according to particular criteria (for example, to
always vote with management, or to vote for or against a proposal to allow a so-called “poison
pill” defense against a possible takeover). These requests must be made in writing. Clients can
also instruct Formative on how to cast their vote in a particular proxy contest by sending an
email to service@firstaffirmative.com.
There is a remote possibility that Formative employees or IARs have a relationship with a public
corporation which may put their interests at odds with those of clients in the Proxy Voting
process. These personnel are required to disclose to the Chief Compliance Officer any such
relationships and are required to recuse themselves from participated in votes related to such
companies.
Clients of advisors using our non-fiduciary services can opt-in to our proxy voting services by
requesting such on the authorization form allowing access to Formative. If the client does not
authorize Formative to vote their proxies according to our Proxy Voting Guidelines at Schwab
Institutional, they should not check the box on the account application authorizing such votes.
If the client does not authorize Formative to vote their proxies at Goldman Sachs, they must
vote their own proxies by logging into their Goldman Sachs account. Any proxies voted by
Formative can be overridden by the client.
Item 7: Client Information Provided to Portfolio Managers
Third-Party Model Managers are investment managers who provide no individualized
investment advice to a client, do not place, or execute transactions on behalf of a client and
merely license proprietary information about the composition of a hypothetical portfolio to
other investment advisors. Accordingly, as a general matter, Third- Party Model Managers on
the Goldman Sachs platform receive no client information.
It should be noted, however, that, when a Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser uses a
Proprietary Model on the Goldman Sachs platform, Formative is both the investment manager
of the model (or portfolio manager) as well as the investment advisor to the client. In its
capacity as an investment advisor, Formative provides individualized investment advice and has
client information.
Item 8: Client Contact with Portfolio Managers
A Third-Party Model Manager generally has no contact of any type with a client, does not
accept investor funds or pool those funds with other investors and does not offer its model
portfolio services to anyone other than other investment advisors. Except as noted below,
clients do not have access to Third-Party Model Managers.
Again, it should be noted, that, when a Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser uses a
Proprietary Model on the Goldman Sachs platform, Formative is both the investment manager
of the model (or portfolio manager) as well as the investment advisor to the client. As an
investment advisor to the client, Formative (through the Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser)
has regular contact with the client.
Item 9: Additional Information
Disciplinary Information
Formative must disclose any legal or disciplinary events material to a client’s or prospective
client’s evaluation of its advisory business or the integrity of its management. Formative, its
management personnel and Investment Adviser Representatives have no disciplinary events to
disclose.
Other Financial Industry Activities and Affiliations
Formative may select BDs to provide brokerage services to client accounts. Conflicts may arise
in the course of Formative’s selection of broker-dealers. Formative recommends BDs and places
orders for the execution of transactions for its clients according to its best execution policies
and procedures and consistent with the client’s investment objectives.
In selecting a BD as a custodian Formative may consider a range of factors it deems relevant,
including, but not limited to cost of services; timing and speed of execution; responsiveness;
creditworthiness and financial stability; likelihood of, and capabilities in, execution, clearance,
and settlement; liquidity in or with an execution venue; and other appropriate factors. After
this analysis, the client has sole discretion as to any Formative approved custodian for a
Managed Mutual Fund Account. However, certain advisory service programs offered by
Formative may only be available through a single custodian.
Formative receives the same compensation for each of the investment options it offers at other
custodians except OPS. Any fees or transaction costs collected by custodians are not shared
with Formative.
Outside Business Activities of Management Personnel and IARs
Formative’s Management Personnel do not have Outside Business Activities that are material
to their roles within Formative.
Several Formative IARs are licensed as insurance agents or as tax preparers. Formative does
not supervise these outside business activities, nor does it share in any of the revenues from
these activities.
Selling Agreement, Solicitors/Endorsers Agreement, and Custodial Relationships
with Formative
There are no referral arrangements between Formative and any RIA firm wherein an individual
is a member, officer, or employee of Formative and is also a member, officer, or employee of
another firm. This includes any other RIA disclosed as required in Section 7.A. on Schedule D of
Form ADV, Part I. (Part I of Formative’s Form ADV is available on the SEC’s website at
www.adviserinfo.sec.gov where you can search by using CRD number 109036). No Formative
client is obligated to use the advisory services of any other RIA, as no other RIA advisory client is
obligated to use Formative’s advisory services.
Managing Other Potential Conflicts
Insider Trading
Formative and/or individuals associated with the firm may buy or sell for their personal
accounts’ securities identical to or different from those recommended to its clients. In addition,
any related person(s) may have an interest or position in a certain security or securities which
may also be recommended to a client. Formative has established written policies and
procedures for insider trading that prohibit any member, officer, or employee of the firm from
buying, selling, or recommending securities where the decision is substantially derived, in
whole or in part, from non-public information, information about other Formative clients or
made based on the potential personal gain of the member, officer or employee.
Compensation Conflicts
Fees Paid to Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers by Formative relating to Discretionary
Investment Management. A portion of the fees for investment advisory services are shared
with Network Advisors or Solicitors/Endorsers to compensate them for their services.
If the Network Advisor is an IAR, Formative compensates the IAR directly, except for any
compensation he or she may earn on the provision of tax preparation services and life
insurance sales.
For Network Advisor and Solicitors/Endorsers, Formative collects the applicable fee from the
client assets and the Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorsers share of the fee is paid to the BD
or RIA firm with whom they are associated, which firm in turn pays a substantial portion of the
fee to the Network Advisor and Solicitor/Endorser. The BD or RIA firm typically retains a small
portion of the Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser share to compensate itself for
administration and other overhead.
Costs and Compensation for Rollover Recommendations. Rollover recommendations have
associated fees payable to Formative and their Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser. These
fees might be more or less than the fees or commissions charged to the Client by the Plan,
other Consultants, or Brokers, as applicable. This creates a conflict of interest. The Network
Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser making the recommendation provides full disclosure of the
associated costs and their compensation so a client can make an informed decision before
accepting the recommendation. This disclosure attempts to mitigate the conflict of interest.
Other Compensation Paid to IARs. In addition to receiving a portion of the fee for discretionary
investment advice, IARs receive a portion of any fees charged for financial planning, hourly
consultation or other services provided under nondiscretionary investment advisory
agreements.
Other Compensation Earned by Third-Party BD, RIA Network Advisors, and
Solicitors/Endorsers. Third-party firms may compensate their advisors for providing other
products or services to clients, Neither Formative nor any Network Advisor or
Solicitor/Endorser receives any transactions-related or variable compensation for the sale of
securities or other investment products, including asset-based sales charges or service fees
from the sale of mutual funds relating to any product or service offered by or on behalf of
Formative.
Formative takes the following steps to address compensation conflicts:
• Discloses to clients that they are not obligated to purchase recommended investment
products from their employees or affiliated companies
• Collects, maintains, and documents accurate, complete, and relevant client background
information, including the client’s financial goals, objectives, and risk tolerance
• The firm’s management conducts regular reviews of client accounts to verify that all
recommendations made to a client are suitable to the client’s needs and circumstances
• Requires that employees seek prior approval of any outside employment activity so that
Formative may ensure that any conflicts of interest in such activities are properly
addressed
• Periodically monitors these outside employment activities to verify that any conflicts of
interest continue to be properly addressed
• Educates employees regarding the responsibilities of a fiduciary, including the need to
have a reasonable and independent basis for investment advice provided to clients; and
• Requires all IARs to acquire and maintain the Accredited Investment Fiduciary (AIF), or
comparable professional designation to provide initial and ongoing training in the duties
of investment fiduciaries.
Clients should be aware that conflicts of interest surrounding compensation may impair the
objectivity of Formative and its members, officers, or employees when making advisory
recommendations or when providing non-discretionary investment advisory services. This
includes a recommendation to rollover retirement assets to an account managed by the
advisor. The Department of Labor’s Rule 3.0, known as the Fiduciary Rule, requires investment
fiduciaries to review the costs associated with rolling over ERISA plan assets to another
retirement vehicle. A conflict of interest occurs if the advisor earns a new fee or increases its
current compensation because of the rollover. Formative offers fee-based compensation which
tends to reduce or change the possibility of conflicts of interest but cannot eliminate them
entirely. While it is Formative’s intent to always offer advice that is in the best interest of the
client, it is the client’s responsibility to evaluate that advice and determine if it is appropriate
before acting. No client is obligated to accept any recommendation, and all clients are free to
implement any recommendation with the broker, planner, or advisor of their choice.
Other Compensation for use of Proprietary Models. Formative recommends multi-manager
models that are proprietary. Formative retains the portion of the revenues allocated for
compensation to model managers. Formative’s models are reviewed against similar non-
proprietary models and are included only if the model is suitable for the client portfolio. Clients
should be aware that conflicts of interest surrounding compensation may impair the objectivity
of Formative and its members, officers, or employees when making advisory recommendations
or when providing non-discretionary investment advisory services. This includes a
recommendation to rollover retirement assets to an account managed by the advisor. A
conflict of interest occurs if the advisor earns a new fee or increases its current compensation
because of the rollover. There also is the possibility of conflicts of interest between clients and
any Network Advisor or Solicitor/Endorser, if the service is provided for variable compensation.
Formative offers fee-based compensation which tends to reduce or change the possibility of
conflicts of interest but cannot eliminate them entirely. While it is Formative’s intent to always
offer advice that is in the best interest of the client, it is the client’s responsibility to evaluate
that advice and determine if it is appropriate before acting. No client is obligated to accept any
recommendation, including recommendations regarding rollovers, and all clients are free to
implement any recommendation with the broker, planner, or advisor of their choice.
Indirect Compensation Specific to Custodians. Formative is charged an annual fee per client
account to OAT for the use of their Astro platform. This technology allows us to design,
implement, and reoptimize portfolios. Formative employs this technology for accounts held at
each of our approved custodians. The fees charged to the Client are the same for each
platform.
Code of Ethics, Review of Accounts, Participation or Interest in Client
Transactions, Personal Trading
Formative has adopted a code of ethics (Code) which sets forth high ethical standards of
business conduct that are required of employees and IARs, including compliance with
applicable federal securities laws.
Formative has adopted the Code to instruct and guide its personnel in their ethical and
fiduciary obligations to clients. The Code also provides rules and requirements regarding the
personal securities trading practices of Formative’s IARs and staff. Formative, its personnel, and
its IARs owe a duty of loyalty, fairness, and good faith toward all clients and are obligated to
adhere not only to the specific provisions of the Code but to the general principles embodied in
the Code. The Code is designed to ensure that the personal securities transactions, activities,
and interests of Formative employees will not interfere with making decisions in the best
interest of advisory clients and implementing such decisions while, at the same time, allowing
employees to invest for their own accounts.
The Code covers a range of topics that include the following: general ethical principles,
reporting of personal securities trading, exceptions to reporting securities transactions,
reportable securities, initial public offerings, and amendments to Form ADV and supervisory
procedures.
A copy of the Code is available to investment advisory clients and prospective clients. You may
request a copy by email sent to Formative’s Chief Compliance Officer, Kathy Lewis at
kathylewis@firstaffirmative.com, or by calling 719-660-6157.
Review of Accounts
Reports to Clients
Clients receive monthly account statements detailing deposits, withdrawals, purchases, sales,
dividends, interest, fees deducted from the account and any other activity, from the custodian
of the account. Clients may also receive trade confirmation of every trade executed in their
account(s), which should be saved for tax purposes.
Formative and its service providers also will make available quarterly performance reports to all
clients. Depending on the custodian and/or the service provider, such performance reports may
be made available for an annual fee, which is not included in the discretionary investment
advisory fees described in Item 4 above.
All clients have online, 24/7 access to their accounts through a Client Portal via the OAT
platform. Formative will provide quarterly performance reports through this Client Portal.
These performance reports may include graphic representations of your accounts using various
data points.
Client Account Reviews
Network Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers. Each Network Advisor and Solicitor/Endorser can
view all positions and activities in his/her client account(s) via the internet, and each Network
Advisor and Solicitor/Endorser receives copies of all reports provided to their client(s). Network
Advisors and Solicitors/Endorsers are expected to review activity in client accounts on a
quarterly basis, to periodically discuss the account with the client, and to ensure the suitability
of the investment services provided based on each client’s specific situation.
Supervising BD or RIA. Each third-party BD and/or RIA with which Formative maintains a selling
or solicitor/endorser’s agreement also is responsible for developing its own, independent
procedures to review client accounts and supervise the activities of its representatives.
Sub-Advisors. Third-Party Model Managers responsible for managing portions of Formative
client accounts are also responsible for ongoing review and supervision of transactions in the
client accounts they manage.
Company Management. Formative’s senior management, including members of the
Investment Committee, conduct both periodic reviews and various systematic samplings of
accounts to supervise and ensure compliance with investment policy. Formative also monitors
the performance of the VADIS portfolio construction workflow.
Client Referrals and Other Compensation
Client Referrals
Formative may pay referral fees to firms (“Solicitors/Endorsers”) for introducing clients. These
fees are asset-based. When the solicitor/endorser is associated with a third-party BD or RIA,
they are paid over the relationship's life. Whenever Formative pays a referral fee, it requires
the Solicitor/Endorser to provide the prospective client with a copy of the Disclosure Brochure
and this document, an Investment Advisory Services Agreement (IAS), and a separate disclosure
statement that includes the following information:
• The Solicitor/Endorser’s name and relationship with Formative
• The fact that the Solicitor/Endorser is being paid a referral fee
• The amount of the fee; and
• As a matter of firm policy, a client working with a Solicitor/Endorser will not be charged
more than any other client.
Other Compensation
It is Formative’s policy not to accept or allow its related persons to accept any form of
compensation, including cash, sales awards, or other prizes, from a non-client in conjunction
with the advisory services it provides to its clients.
Financial Information
Under no circumstances does Formative require or solicit payment of fees in excess of $500 per
client more than six months in advance of services rendered. Therefore, Formative is not
required to include a financial statement in this disclosure document.
As an advisory firm that maintains discretionary authority for client accounts and maintains
custody of client assets held for clients at Schwab, SEI, and Apex, granting Formative
authorization under a SLOA, Formative is also required to disclose any financial condition that is
reasonably likely to impair its ability to meet its contractual obligations. Formative has no
additional financial circumstances to report.
Formative’s financial statements are audited or reviewed each calendar year by a qualified,
independent CPA firm.
Formative has never been the subject of a bankruptcy petition.